I have only met one piano student who actually enjoyed practicing scales. She was a very organized, analytical person who found the “rules” of scales comforting.
Every other student has sighed, groaned, avoided, detested and otherwise vehemently wished scales would just disappear.
I can’t really blame them. Scales are like the spinach of piano lessons. You know it’s good for you… so you choke it down… but you would really rather not.
6 Ways To Take The “Snore” Out of Scales
Because the benefits of regular scale reinforcement are so valuable I recently set out on a quest to make scales a little more palatable. While the following six activities may not turn spinach into cotton candy… they might be like those yummy bacon bits that permit spinach salad to be included on a menu 😉
1. Mid-way Madness
Call out a scale and a scale degree. Next, instruct your student to start the given scale from that point. For example – shouting “mediant!” for a C minor hamonic scale would mean your student would start with her 3 finger on Eb and continue up the scale. To make it even more difficult, call out a second scale degree on which they need to finish.
2. Contrary Call-Out
Call out a scale. Next, instruct your student to place both of her thumbs on the tonic (thumbs should be sharing the key) and then (in contrary motion) play the first 5 notes (only) using the correct fingering. The contrary motion will solidify her knowledge of the fingering and the accidentals in the scale (each hand is playing something different). This game becomes really fun when you start calling out a variety of scales rapidly… without giving your student a break in between.
3. Crush It
Call out a scale and then instruct your student to use her 1 through 5 fingers in both hands to “crush down” the first 5 notes of the scale. For example, if you called out “F major”, the F, G, A, Bb and C keys would all be depressed at once.
This game becomes really fun when you allow your student to a) crush the keys loudly and b) move between requests rapidly.
4. Scale Hurdles
If you have track and field kids in your piano studio they’ll understand hurdles. If you don’t, you might want to show them a youtube video 😉 To play Scale Hurdles, select two notes in a scale and cover the corresponding keys on the keyboard with small post-its. Instruct your student to play the scale while “hurdling” over the marked keys (skipping over them without actually playing them).
See how quickly your student can complete the scale without “knocking over a hurdle” (accidentally playing the key). If you have a blossoming Scale Hurdle Athlete in your studio, up the ante by having her play the scale hands together and placing the “hurdles” on different keys in each hand
5. Dizzy Degrees
Select a scale and then call out a varying arrangement of scale degrees. Next, have your student… a) play the correct scale degrees using the correct accidentals, b) play each scale degree with the finger that is typically required in that scale and c) play each scale degree in the order requested.
For example, in the C Major scale you could call out “Dominant, Leading Tone, Mediant” and your student would play G with her 2 finger, B with their 4 finger and E with her 3 finger. Your student’s hand should lift with each key she plays in a bouncing motion. See how fast can she can complete your requests and how many degrees you can call out before she gets mixed up?
6. Never Would I Ever…
Call out “Never would I ever…” and then complete this sentence in one of the following two ways:
- Insert an incorrect accidental “Never would I ever add an F# to a C minor scale”
- Insert a correct accidental “Never would I ever add an G# to a E Major scale”
Instruct your student to decide (as quickly as possible) if your sentence is true or false. If it’s true she plays the scale (correctly). If its false she plays nothing. If she makes a mistake in determining “true or false”… she has to play the scale three times over 🙂
More Piano Activities To Turn Boring Into Brilliant…
Scales, theory, sight reading… all of these things don’t need to be boring! With a good dose of creative energy your piano kids can actually look forward to the parts of their lessons that they used to dread. And… if you’re looking for creative energy you’re in the right place! Our PianoGameClub theory and ear training games are exactly what you need to make these aspects of your piano lesson absolutely amazing!
Elaine says
Brilliant post, thank you so much – so much more fun, and I’m sure will have so much more learning power than the endless mindless repetition I used to have to do as a student.
Read it then dashed off to the piano to play Scale Hurdles by myself….
Andrea says
Hi Elaine – thanks for commenting! We hope it makes scales more fun for your students too (and that you had fun with Scale Hurdles this morning 😉 )
Sam Marion says
These are great ideas. I found some dice at a local store that sells dice with Roman numerals on them. I could use these with your Dizzy Degrees activity. I have been using them for interesting chord sequences.
Ann says
Thanks for your really great ways to make scales interesting. I wish my teacher had thought of some of them when I was learning scales.
Just wondered if in 5 it should read G with finger 2 (or am I not working it out correctly?)
Thanks for sharing these.
Linda H. says
I thought the same.
Trevor says
Oops! Typo fixed… thanks Ann!
Linda H. says
Great little ideas! I always do scales and I’m always trying to come up with variations to wake up the students’ brains because after awhile scales are just mechanical. Good to some degree, but yes, a “snore”, too. So thank you! Now I have some new ideas to use!
Kathy says
How fun! Sure wish I had learned such creative ways to learn scales.
Question: After 30+ years of teaching general music and recorder classes privately, I am just now beginning to teach beginning piano to all ages. My question is “when should I begin to introduce the scales?”
With my older students I do 5-tone scale in C and G major. So far the book series I use (Faber) hasn’t introduced it.
Andrea says
Hi Kathy – we’ve blogged about this too to hopefully answer your question! Link is here: https://www.teachpianotoday.com/2016/02/01/where-to-start-with-scales-when-you-dont-know-where-to-start-with-scales/
Jason Boyd says
Fantastic ideas especially for youngsters. Thanks!
Chris says
I really like #6, “Never Would I Ever….”
This game is brilliant “spoonful of sugar,” not only to make the “medicine” of practicing those scales “go down,” but also to make them actually seem fun and desirable to play, and the possibilities built into the game create excitement!
Andrea says
Hope you have fun with them Chris!… And now that Mary Poppins song is stuck in my head
Andrea says
Absolutely brilliant ideas! Thank so much for sharing your wealth of knowledge! 🙂
Jenna says
Brilliant ideas — again! I can’t wait to use these in my lessons! I can think of a few students who would love this; thank you!
Tia says
Would you please describe the example in the number 1? It sounds interesting but I need more detail :o) thanks